0.11/0.13 % Problem : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0. 0.11/0.14 % Command : run_portfolio.sh /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p /export/starexec/sandbox/tmp/tmp.xcir8aHEul 0.14/0.35 % Computer : n017.cluster.edu 0.14/0.35 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 0.14/0.35 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 0.14/0.35 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 0.14/0.35 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 0.14/0.35 % CPULimit : 180 0.14/0.35 % DateTime : Thu Aug 29 12:04:19 EDT 2019 0.14/0.36 % CPUTime : 20.30/20.51 % Running portfolio for 180 s 20.30/20.51 % File : /export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p 20.30/20.51 % TempDir : /export/starexec/sandbox/tmp/tmp.xcir8aHEul 20.30/20.51 % Recognized as monomorphic HO. 20.30/20.51 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/competitive.sh for 18 20.30/20.51 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/competitive.2.sh for 14 20.30/20.51 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/competitive.3.sh for 4 20.30/20.51 % Running /export/starexec/sandbox/solver/bin/pragmatic.rudimentary.sh for 31 20.30/20.51 % Solved by: pragmatic.rudimentary.sh 20.30/20.51 % done 790 iterations in 0.376s 20.30/20.51 % hashcons stats for terms: size 4096, num 1781, sum length 12764, buckets: small 3, median 3, big 13 20.30/20.51 % proof state stats: {active 551, passive 1962, simpl 0} 20.30/20.51 % SZS status Theorem for '/export/starexec/sandbox/benchmark/theBenchmark.p' 20.30/20.51 % SZS output start Refutation 20.30/20.51 tff(o, axiom, o() = ^[X:reg,Y:reg]: (?[Z:reg]: (p(Z,Y) & p(Z,X)))). 20.30/20.51 tff('0', plain, 20.30/20.51 o = (^[V_1:reg,V_2:reg]: (?[X2:reg]: (p(X2,V_2) & p(X2,V_1)))), 20.30/20.51 define([status(thm)])). 20.30/20.51 tff(p, axiom, p() = ^[X:reg,Y:reg]: (![Z:reg]: (c(Z,X) => c(Z,Y)))). 20.30/20.51 tff('1', plain, 20.30/20.51 p = (^[V_1:reg,V_2:reg]: (![X2:reg]: (c(X2,V_1) => c(X2,V_2)))), 20.30/20.51 define([status(thm)])). 20.30/20.51 tff(mvalid, axiom, mvalid() = ^[Phi:($i > $o)]: (![W]: Phi(W))). 20.30/20.51 tff('2', plain, mvalid = (^[V_1:($i > $o)]: (![X2]: V_1(X2))), 20.30/20.51 define([status(thm)])). 20.30/20.51 tff(mbox, axiom, mbox() = 20.30/20.51 ^[R:(($i * $i) > $o),Phi:($i > $o),W]: (![V]: (Phi(V) | (~R(W,V))))). 20.30/20.51 tff('3', plain, 20.30/20.51 mbox = 20.30/20.51 (^[V_1:(($i * $i) > $o),V_2:($i > $o),V_3]: 20.30/20.51 (![X2]: (V_2(X2) | (~V_1(V_3,X2))))), 20.30/20.51 define([status(thm)])). 20.30/20.51 tff(con, conjecture, 20.30/20.51 (mvalid(mbox(a, 20.30/20.51 ^[X]: 20.30/20.51 (![Z:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((o(Z,catalunya) | o(Z,paris)) => 20.30/20.51 (o(Z,france) | o(Z,spain)))))))). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_0, conjecture, 20.30/20.51 (![X2,X3]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X4:reg]: 20.30/20.51 (((?[X5:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X6:reg]: (c(X6,X5) => c(X6,catalunya))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X7:reg]: (c(X7,X5) => c(X7,X4))))) | 20.30/20.51 (?[X8:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X9:reg]: (c(X9,X8) => c(X9,paris))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X10:reg]: (c(X10,X8) => c(X10,X4)))))) => 20.30/20.51 ((?[X11:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X12:reg]: (c(X12,X11) => c(X12,france))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X13:reg]: (c(X13,X11) => c(X13,X4))))) | 20.30/20.51 (?[X14:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X15:reg]: (c(X15,X14) => c(X15,spain))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X16:reg]: (c(X16,X14) => c(X16,X4)))))))) | 20.30/20.51 (~a(X2,X3))))). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_1, negated_conjecture, 20.30/20.51 (~ 20.30/20.51 (![X2,X3]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X4:reg]: 20.30/20.51 (((?[X5:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X6:reg]: (c(X6,X5) => c(X6,catalunya))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X7:reg]: (c(X7,X5) => c(X7,X4))))) | 20.30/20.51 (?[X8:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X9:reg]: (c(X9,X8) => c(X9,paris))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X10:reg]: (c(X10,X8) => c(X10,X4)))))) => 20.30/20.51 ((?[X11:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X12:reg]: (c(X12,X11) => c(X12,france))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X13:reg]: (c(X13,X11) => c(X13,X4))))) | 20.30/20.51 (?[X14:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X15:reg]: (c(X15,X14) => c(X15,spain))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X16:reg]: (c(X16,X14) => c(X16,X4)))))))) | 20.30/20.51 (~a(X2,X3)))))). 20.30/20.51 tff('4', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X121 : reg]: (c(sk_X15_(X121), X121) | c(sk_X16_(X121), X121)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 20.30/20.51 tff('5', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X123 : reg, X124 : reg]: 20.30/20.51 (~ c(X123, sk_X5_) 20.30/20.51 | c(X123, catalunya) 20.30/20.51 | c(X124, paris) 20.30/20.51 | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 20.30/20.51 tff('6', plain, 20.30/20.51 (![X123 : reg]: (~ c(X123, sk_X5_) | c(X123, catalunya))) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X123 : reg]: (~ c(X123, sk_X5_) | c(X123, catalunya)))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['5'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('7', plain, 20.30/20.51 ((c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_) | c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), catalunya))) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X123 : reg]: (~ c(X123, sk_X5_) | c(X123, catalunya)))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['4', '6'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('8', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), catalunya)) | (c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_)) | 20.30/20.51 ~ (![X123 : reg]: (~ c(X123, sk_X5_) | c(X123, catalunya))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['7'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('9', plain, 20.30/20.51 (![X123 : reg]: (~ c(X123, sk_X5_) | c(X123, catalunya))) | 20.30/20.51 (![X124 : reg]: (c(X124, paris) | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['5'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('10', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X122 : reg]: (c(sk_X12_(X122), X122) | c(sk_X13_(X122), X122)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 20.30/20.51 tff('11', plain, 20.30/20.51 (![X124 : reg]: (c(X124, paris) | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_))) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X124 : reg]: (c(X124, paris) | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_)))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['5'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('12', plain, 20.30/20.51 ((c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X8_) | c(sk_X12_(sk_X8_), paris))) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X124 : reg]: (c(X124, paris) | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_)))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['10', '11'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('13', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X8_)) | 20.30/20.51 ~ (![X124 : reg]: (c(X124, paris) | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_))) | 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X12_(sk_X8_), paris)), inference('split', [status(esa)], ['12'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('14', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X12_(sk_X8_), paris)) <= ((c(sk_X12_(sk_X8_), paris))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['12'])). 20.30/20.51 tff(ntpp, axiom, ntpp() = 20.30/20.51 ^[X:reg,Y:reg]: ((~(?[Z:reg]: (ec(Z,Y) & ec(Z,X)))) & pp(X,Y))). 20.30/20.51 tff('15', plain, 20.30/20.51 ntpp = 20.30/20.51 (^[V_1:reg,V_2:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((~(?[X2:reg]: (ec(X2,V_2) & ec(X2,V_1)))) & pp(V_1,V_2))), 20.30/20.51 define([status(thm)])). 20.30/20.51 tff(pp, axiom, pp() = ^[X:reg,Y:reg]: ((~p(Y,X)) & p(X,Y))). 20.30/20.51 tff('16', plain, pp = (^[V_1:reg,V_2:reg]: ((~p(V_2,V_1)) & p(V_1,V_2))), 20.30/20.51 define([status(thm)])). 20.30/20.51 tff(ec, axiom, ec() = ^[X:reg,Y:reg]: ((~o(X,Y)) & c(X,Y))). 20.30/20.51 tff('17', plain, ec = (^[V_1:reg,V_2:reg]: ((~o(V_1,V_2)) & c(V_1,V_2))), 20.30/20.51 define([status(thm)])). 20.30/20.51 tff(ax3, axiom, (mvalid(mbox(a,^[X]: ntpp(paris,france))))). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_2, axiom, 20.30/20.51 (![X2,X3]: 20.30/20.51 ((~a(X2,X3)) | 20.30/20.51 ((~(![X11:reg]: (c(X11,france) => c(X11,paris)))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X12:reg]: (c(X12,paris) => c(X12,france))) & 20.30/20.51 (~ 20.30/20.51 (?[X4:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((~ 20.30/20.51 (?[X8:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X10:reg]: (c(X10,X8) => c(X10,X4))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X9:reg]: (c(X9,X8) => c(X9,paris)))))) & 20.30/20.51 c(X4,paris) & 20.30/20.51 (~ 20.30/20.51 (?[X5:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X7:reg]: (c(X7,X5) => c(X7,X4))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X6:reg]: (c(X6,X5) => c(X6,france)))))) & 20.30/20.51 c(X4,france)))))))). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_3, type, zip_tseitin1 : (reg * reg) > $o). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_4, axiom, 20.30/20.51 (zip_tseitin1(X5,X4) => 20.30/20.51 ((![X6:reg]: (c(X6,X5) => c(X6,france))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X7:reg]: (c(X7,X5) => c(X7,X4)))))). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_5, type, zip_tseitin0 : (reg * reg) > $o). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_6, axiom, 20.30/20.51 (zip_tseitin0(X8,X4) => 20.30/20.51 ((![X9:reg]: (c(X9,X8) => c(X9,paris))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X10:reg]: (c(X10,X8) => c(X10,X4)))))). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_7, axiom, 20.30/20.51 (![X2,X3]: 20.30/20.51 (((~ 20.30/20.51 (?[X4:reg]: 20.30/20.51 (c(X4,france) & (~(?[X5:reg]: zip_tseitin1(X5,X4))) & 20.30/20.51 c(X4,paris) & (~(?[X8:reg]: zip_tseitin0(X8,X4)))))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X12:reg]: (c(X12,paris) => c(X12,france))) & 20.30/20.51 (~(![X11:reg]: (c(X11,france) => c(X11,paris))))) | 20.30/20.51 (~a(X2,X3))))). 20.30/20.51 tff('18', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X135, X136, X137 : reg]: 20.30/20.51 (~ c(X137, paris) | c(X137, france) | ~ a(X135, X136)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_7])). 20.30/20.51 tff('19', plain, 20.30/20.51 (![X137 : reg]: (~ c(X137, paris) | c(X137, france))) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X137 : reg]: (~ c(X137, paris) | c(X137, france)))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['18'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('20', plain, 20.30/20.51 (![X137 : reg]: (~ c(X137, paris) | c(X137, france))) | 20.30/20.51 (![X135, X136]: ~ a(X135, X136)), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['18'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('21', plain, a(sk_X2_, sk_X3_), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 20.30/20.51 tff('22', plain, ![X135, X136]: (~ c(sk_X11_, paris) | ~ a(X135, X136)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_7])). 20.30/20.51 tff('23', plain, 20.30/20.51 (![X135, X136]: ~ a(X135, X136)) <= ((![X135, X136]: ~ a(X135, X136))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['22'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('24', plain, ~ (![X135, X136]: ~ a(X135, X136)), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['21', '23'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('25', plain, (![X137 : reg]: (~ c(X137, paris) | c(X137, france))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sat_resolution', [status(thm)], ['20', '24'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('26', plain, ![X137 : reg]: (~ c(X137, paris) | c(X137, france)), 20.30/20.51 inference('simpl_trail', [status(thm)], ['19', '25'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('27', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X12_(sk_X8_), france)) <= ((c(sk_X12_(sk_X8_), paris))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['14', '26'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('28', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X122 : reg]: (~ c(sk_X12_(X122), france) | c(sk_X13_(X122), X122)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 20.30/20.51 tff('29', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X8_)) <= ((c(sk_X12_(sk_X8_), paris))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['27', '28'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('30', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X123 : reg, X125 : reg]: 20.30/20.51 (~ c(X123, sk_X5_) 20.30/20.51 | c(X123, catalunya) 20.30/20.51 | c(X125, sk_X4_1) 20.30/20.51 | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 20.30/20.51 tff('31', plain, 20.30/20.51 (![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_))) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_)))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['30'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('32', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X4_1)) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_))) & 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X12_(sk_X8_), paris))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['29', '31'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('33', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X122 : reg]: (~ c(sk_X12_(X122), france) | ~ c(sk_X13_(X122), sk_X4_1)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 20.30/20.51 tff('34', plain, 20.30/20.51 (~ c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X4_1)) <= ((c(sk_X12_(sk_X8_), paris))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['27', '33'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('35', plain, 20.30/20.51 ~ (c(sk_X12_(sk_X8_), paris)) | 20.30/20.51 ~ (![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['32', '34'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('36', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X8_)) <= ((c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['12'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('37', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X4_1)) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_))) & 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['36', '31'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('38', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X122 : reg]: (c(sk_X12_(X122), X122) | ~ c(sk_X13_(X122), sk_X4_1)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 20.30/20.51 tff('39', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X12_(sk_X8_), sk_X8_)) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_))) & 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['37', '38'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('40', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X12_(sk_X8_), paris)) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X124 : reg]: (c(X124, paris) | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_))) & 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['39', '11'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('41', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X12_(sk_X8_), france)) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X124 : reg]: (c(X124, paris) | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_))) & 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['40', '26'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('42', plain, 20.30/20.51 (~ c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X4_1)) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X124 : reg]: (c(X124, paris) | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_))) & 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['41', '33'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('43', plain, 20.30/20.51 ~ (c(sk_X13_(sk_X8_), sk_X8_)) | 20.30/20.51 ~ (![X124 : reg]: (c(X124, paris) | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_))) | 20.30/20.51 ~ (![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['37', '42'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('44', plain, 20.30/20.51 ~ (![X124 : reg]: (c(X124, paris) | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_))) | 20.30/20.51 ~ (![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sat_resolution', [status(thm)], ['13', '35', '43'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('45', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), catalunya)) <= ((c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), catalunya))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['7'])). 20.30/20.51 tff(tpp, axiom, tpp() = 20.30/20.51 ^[X:reg,Y:reg]: ((?[Z:reg]: (ec(Z,Y) & ec(Z,X))) & pp(X,Y))). 20.30/20.51 tff('46', plain, 20.30/20.51 tpp = 20.30/20.51 (^[V_1:reg,V_2:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((?[X2:reg]: (ec(X2,V_2) & ec(X2,V_1))) & pp(V_1,V_2))), 20.30/20.51 define([status(thm)])). 20.30/20.51 tff(ax1, axiom, (mvalid(mbox(a,^[X]: tpp(catalunya,spain))))). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_8, axiom, 20.30/20.51 (![X2,X3]: 20.30/20.51 ((~a(X2,X3)) | 20.30/20.51 ((~(![X11:reg]: (c(X11,spain) => c(X11,catalunya)))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X12:reg]: (c(X12,catalunya) => c(X12,spain))) & 20.30/20.51 (?[X4:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((~ 20.30/20.51 (?[X8:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X10:reg]: (c(X10,X8) => c(X10,X4))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X9:reg]: (c(X9,X8) => c(X9,catalunya)))))) & 20.30/20.51 c(X4,catalunya) & 20.30/20.51 (~ 20.30/20.51 (?[X5:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X7:reg]: (c(X7,X5) => c(X7,X4))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X6:reg]: (c(X6,X5) => c(X6,spain)))))) & 20.30/20.51 c(X4,spain))))))). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_9, type, zip_tseitin7 : (reg * reg) > $o). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_10, axiom, ((c(X6,X5) => c(X6,spain)) => zip_tseitin7(X6,X5))). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_11, type, zip_tseitin6 : (reg * reg * reg) > $o). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_12, axiom, ((c(X7,X5) => c(X7,X4)) => zip_tseitin6(X7,X5,X4))). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_13, type, zip_tseitin5 : (reg * reg) > $o). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_14, axiom, 20.30/20.51 ((c(X9,X8) => c(X9,catalunya)) => zip_tseitin5(X9,X8))). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_15, type, zip_tseitin4 : (reg * reg * reg) > $o). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_16, axiom, ((c(X10,X8) => c(X10,X4)) => zip_tseitin4(X10,X8,X4))). 20.30/20.51 tff(zf_stmt_17, axiom, 20.30/20.51 (![X2,X3]: 20.30/20.51 (((?[X4:reg]: 20.30/20.51 (c(X4,spain) & 20.30/20.51 (~ 20.30/20.51 (?[X5:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X6:reg]: zip_tseitin7(X6,X5)) & 20.30/20.51 (![X7:reg]: zip_tseitin6(X7,X5,X4))))) & 20.30/20.51 c(X4,catalunya) & 20.30/20.51 (~ 20.30/20.51 (?[X8:reg]: 20.30/20.51 ((![X9:reg]: zip_tseitin5(X9,X8)) & 20.30/20.51 (![X10:reg]: zip_tseitin4(X10,X8,X4))))))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X12:reg]: (c(X12,catalunya) => c(X12,spain))) & 20.30/20.51 (~(![X11:reg]: (c(X11,spain) => c(X11,catalunya))))) | 20.30/20.51 (~a(X2,X3))))). 20.30/20.51 tff('47', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X152, X153, X155 : reg]: 20.30/20.51 (~ c(X155, catalunya) | c(X155, spain) | ~ a(X152, X153)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_17])). 20.30/20.51 tff('48', plain, 20.30/20.51 (![X155 : reg]: (~ c(X155, catalunya) | c(X155, spain))) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X155 : reg]: (~ c(X155, catalunya) | c(X155, spain)))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['47'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('49', plain, 20.30/20.51 (![X155 : reg]: (~ c(X155, catalunya) | c(X155, spain))) | 20.30/20.51 (![X135, X136]: ~ a(X135, X136)), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['47'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('50', plain, (![X155 : reg]: (~ c(X155, catalunya) | c(X155, spain))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sat_resolution', [status(thm)], ['49', '24'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('51', plain, ![X155 : reg]: (~ c(X155, catalunya) | c(X155, spain)), 20.30/20.51 inference('simpl_trail', [status(thm)], ['48', '50'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('52', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), spain)) <= ((c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), catalunya))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['45', '51'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('53', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X121 : reg]: (~ c(sk_X15_(X121), spain) | c(sk_X16_(X121), X121)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 20.30/20.51 tff('54', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_)) <= ((c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), catalunya))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['52', '53'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('55', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X124 : reg, X126 : reg]: 20.30/20.51 (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) 20.30/20.51 | c(X126, sk_X4_1) 20.30/20.51 | c(X124, paris) 20.30/20.51 | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 20.30/20.51 tff('56', plain, 20.30/20.51 (![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1))) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1)))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['55'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('57', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X4_1)) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1))) & 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), catalunya))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['54', '56'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('58', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X121 : reg]: (~ c(sk_X15_(X121), spain) | ~ c(sk_X16_(X121), sk_X4_1)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 20.30/20.51 tff('59', plain, 20.30/20.51 (~ c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X4_1)) <= ((c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), catalunya))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['52', '58'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('60', plain, 20.30/20.51 ~ (c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), catalunya)) | 20.30/20.51 ~ (![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['57', '59'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('61', plain, 20.30/20.51 ((c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_) | c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), sk_X4_1))) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1)))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['4', '56'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('62', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_)) <= ((c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['61'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('63', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X4_1)) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1))) & 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['62', '56'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('64', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X121 : reg]: (c(sk_X15_(X121), X121) | ~ c(sk_X16_(X121), sk_X4_1)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 20.30/20.51 tff('65', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_)) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1))) & 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['63', '64'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('66', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), catalunya)) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X123 : reg]: (~ c(X123, sk_X5_) | c(X123, catalunya))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1))) & 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['65', '6'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('67', plain, 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), spain)) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X123 : reg]: (~ c(X123, sk_X5_) | c(X123, catalunya))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1))) & 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['66', '51'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('68', plain, 20.30/20.51 (~ c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X4_1)) 20.30/20.51 <= ((![X123 : reg]: (~ c(X123, sk_X5_) | c(X123, catalunya))) & 20.30/20.51 (![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1))) & 20.30/20.51 (c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['67', '58'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('69', plain, 20.30/20.51 ~ (c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_)) | 20.30/20.51 ~ (![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1))) | 20.30/20.51 ~ (![X123 : reg]: (~ c(X123, sk_X5_) | c(X123, catalunya))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sup-', [status(thm)], ['63', '68'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('70', plain, 20.30/20.51 ![X125 : reg, X126 : reg]: 20.30/20.51 (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) 20.30/20.51 | c(X126, sk_X4_1) 20.30/20.51 | c(X125, sk_X4_1) 20.30/20.51 | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_)), 20.30/20.51 inference('cnf', [status(esa)], [zf_stmt_1])). 20.30/20.51 tff('71', plain, 20.30/20.51 (![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1))) | 20.30/20.51 (![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['70'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('72', plain, 20.30/20.51 (![X123 : reg]: (~ c(X123, sk_X5_) | c(X123, catalunya))) | 20.30/20.51 (![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['30'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('73', plain, (![X125 : reg]: (c(X125, sk_X4_1) | ~ c(X125, sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sat_resolution', [status(thm)], ['8', '60', '69', '71', '72'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('74', plain, ~ (![X124 : reg]: (c(X124, paris) | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sat_resolution', [status(thm)], ['44', '73'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('75', plain, (![X123 : reg]: (~ c(X123, sk_X5_) | c(X123, catalunya))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sat_resolution', [status(thm)], ['9', '74'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('76', plain, 20.30/20.51 (![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1))) | 20.30/20.51 (![X124 : reg]: (c(X124, paris) | ~ c(X124, sk_X8_))), 20.30/20.51 inference('split', [status(esa)], ['55'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('77', plain, (![X126 : reg]: (~ c(X126, sk_X5_) | c(X126, sk_X4_1))), 20.30/20.51 inference('sat_resolution', [status(thm)], ['76', '74'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('78', plain, ~ (c(sk_X16_(sk_X5_), sk_X5_)), 20.30/20.51 inference('sat_resolution', [status(thm)], ['69', '75', '77'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('79', plain, ~ (c(sk_X15_(sk_X5_), catalunya)), 20.30/20.51 inference('sat_resolution', [status(thm)], ['60', '77'])). 20.30/20.51 tff('80', plain, $false, 20.30/20.51 inference('sat_resolution', [status(thm)], ['8', '75', '78', '79'])). 20.30/20.51 20.30/20.51 % SZS output end Refutation 20.30/20.51 % Zipperpin 1.5 exiting 20.30/20.51 EOF